Skip to main content

Have I started hating mysql and falling in love with distributed databases

It seems Mysql is rock solid if you want:
  1. Transactions
  2. ACID support
So I would still recommend mysql for any thing that is mission critical data and it should be the primary datastore for your transactions. But what about derived data, immutable data or analytical data?

In past I have built large scale cluster of mysql server storing metadata about billions of files and folders used by tens of thousands of customers daily and its scaling fine and working good, its still growing at a healthy rate and holding up.  But this requires a lot of baby sitting if you have 100s of nodes and you need to do
  1. replication
  2. add more nodes
  3. rebalancing data
  4. monitoring entire cluster
  5. Sharding
  6. Backup/restore
You have to write a lot of tooling and lot of monitoring/babysitting to scale the cluster. Plain stock Mysql will scale up to a limit but vertically scaling has its own issues. So +1 for Mysql but not everything should be stuffed there.

Recently me and my team built full text search/indexing on same dataset using elasticsearch and so far it hasn’t disappointed me. With just 1 engineer and 1 devops guy we are able to build a cluster per datacenter to store same data. The thing I liked most about Elasticsearch was half way through migration we started facing performance issues and we just added more nodes and the cluster rebalanced itself.  Also Elasticsearch has tools like kopf/HQ where I can monitor all nodes in one place.  For e.g. this is one of the smallest cluster that we just started migrating and as it grows if we see high load averages then we can add more data or client nodes.

I don’t need an lot of DBAs to manage the cluster as elasticsearch has built in support for
  1. replication
  2. adding more nodes
  3. rebalancing data
  4. monitoring entire cluster
  5. Sharding
I had earlier built an event store to store events on top of mysql but I was storing only few months of events into it. Now I have to build a store that can store events for 7 years and I dont want to use Mysql for it as I dont want to baby sit it. Our events data is way huge than the metadata. Because every change to a file generates an event and over 7 years this could be a huge no of records. I dont want to manage an army of mysql servers so researching for some database that has good querying support and can store long lived data with eventual consistency and rock solid durability. You could store them using kafka or scribe but they lack good querying support.  I am still not sure if Elasticsearch is a good store for this because I don’t need search, I need querying based on some paths and time based querying. Also most querying will be on recent data and past data would be queried rarely. Logstash uses Elasticsearch in same fashion so I need to find something else and then compare with Elasticsearch.

Also I see a trend emerging that in today's world DBAs need to get out of cocoon and know more than just relational databases. There are a lot of new tools like OpenTSDB, HBase, Mongo, Cassandra, ElasticSearch, BigQuery that are now getting used to store BigData so they need to catch up and catch up fast. Google recently released BigTable need to check it out. I had checked BigQuery but writes are cheap, its the reads that are costly when using things like BigQuery.


Popular posts from this blog

RabbitMQ java clients for beginners

Here is a sample of a consumer and producer example for RabbitMQ. The steps are
Download ErlangDownload Rabbit MQ ServerDownload Rabbit MQ Java client jarsCompile and run the below two class and you are done.
This sample create a Durable Exchange, Queue and a Message. You will have to start the consumer first before you start the for the first time.

For more information on AMQP, Exchanges, Queues, read this excellent tutorial
import com.rabbitmq.client.Connection; import com.rabbitmq.client.Channel; import com.rabbitmq.client.*; public class RabbitMQProducer { public static void main(String []args) throws Exception { ConnectionFactory factory = new ConnectionFactory(); factory.setUsername("guest"); factory.setPassword("guest"); factory.setVirtualHost("/"); factory.setHost(""); factory.setPort(5672); Conne…

Logging to Graphite monitoring tool from java

We use Graphite as a tool for monitoring some stats and watch trends. A requirement is to monitor impact of new releases as build is deployed to app nodes to see if things like
1) Has the memcache usage increased.
2) Has the no of Java exceptions went up.
3) Is the app using more tomcat threads.
Here is a screenshot

We changed the installer to log a deploy event when a new build is deployed. I wrote a simple spring bean to log graphite events using java. Logging to graphite is easy, all you need to do is open a socket and send lines of events.
import org.slf4j.Logger;import org.slf4j.LoggerFactory; import; import; import; import java.util.HashMap; import java.util.Map; public class GraphiteLogger { private static final Logger logger = LoggerFactory.getLogger(GraphiteLogger.class); private String graphiteHost; private int graphitePort; public String getGraphiteHost() { return graphiteHost; } public void setGraphite…

Jersey posting multipart data

This took me sometime to figure out mostly it was because I was only including jersey-multipart-1.6.jar but I was not including mimepull-1.3.jar.

So the intent is to upload a file using REST api and we need pass meta attributes in addition to uploading the file. Also the intent is to stream the file instead of first storing it on the local disk. Here is some sample code.
@Path("/upload-service") public class UploadService { @Context protected HttpServletResponse response; @Context protected HttpServletRequest request; @POST @Consumes(MediaType.MULTIPART_FORM_DATA) @Produces(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON) public String uploadFile(@PathParam("fileName") final String fileName, @FormDataParam("workgroupId") String workgroupId, @FormDataParam("userId") final int userId, @FormDataParam("content") final InputStream content) throws JSONException { //.......Upload the file to S3 or netapp or any storage service } }
Now to tes…